Home Page
04. 9.2007 (previous | next)
CNET on anti-Microsoft Sentiments

By attorney Lars Liebeler, in CNET, a discussion of recent antitrust actions here and abroad, in particular scrutiny of the Novell/Microsoft agreement.

Each generation has its antitrust bogeyman from Standard Oil down to AT&T & IBM. The short-run obsession in policy circles with a single company (when policy properly conceived ought to be anonymous for the best results in the long run) invites gaming the system, and results in exceptions dominating what ought to be the rules to an alarming extent. Principled resistance to this tendency is very weak in the EU, where fines are seized on to feed growing armies of bureaucrats in Brussels and the trend is fueled by anti-Americanism.

posted by Solveig Singleton @ 8:09 AM | Antitrust, Software

Link to this Entry | Printer-Friendly | Email a Comment | Post a Comment(2)


Comments

One could also say:

"Each generation of Americans have their own European bogeyman from King George down to de Gaulle..."

But, seriously, Standard Oil, AT&T and IBM were each restrained by operation of law within America. A fair observer would say that American Law has failed in this regard, in the case of Microsoft. You may say that that law against monopolies is not a good law. Fair enough.

However, if we are to maintain this global system of trading, we have to be ready to compromise. The global system should not be built only according to the wishes of America, and in particular, large American Corporations.

Now that another jurisdiction's laws apply in a way different than those in America believe they should apply, suddenly, somehow, it has to be UNFAIR.

Well, that is how the rest of the world feels when America forces laws similar to the DMCA act down their throats. This is to say nothing of TRIPS and the WTO. It seems that America almost always gets the world trading rules written to its specifications. Sometimes, though some other values from some other countries seep in that are foreign to interests of large American corporations.

My response: Welcome to Globalization.

Given the dangers to liberty that large corporations represent (the DMCA is only the tip of the iceberg) it is in the interests of the American people to see the power of these corporations diminished.

Oh, and BTW, Microsoft has been given every chance to comply with the rules of the EU. They have ignored those laws and been extremely arrogant. At a minimum, one should read the testimony of Andrew Tridgell (the author of Samba) for an explanation of why Microsoft did not comply, and what it should have done.

It is notable that one of the supposed 'commentators' on the EU's treatment of Microsoft over at IPCentral, Mr. Noel Le, did not even know who Andrew Tridgell was. How can that be?

Posted by: enigma_foundry at April 10, 2007 8:32 PM

Mr. E, you must be trying to set Tridgell's place in history.

Posted by: Noel at April 11, 2007 10:45 PM








 
IPcentral WebLog

Blog Main

IPcentral Blogosphere Archives

Search the Blog

Recent Posts
  - IP and Marginal Cost
- Academics and Copyright
- More on Jammie Thomas from DOJ
- More Studies of Downloading
- Facebook, MySpace, and Network Externalities
- Copyright and the University: An Academic Symposium
- Tyler Cowan on Chinese Movie Piracy
- More WHO Antics--Roger Bate Reports
- Patents, Meds, and the Developing World: Clips & Links
- Jermaine Dupri's Gripe with iTunes
Archives by Month
  - December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
  - (see all)
Archives by Subject
  - Academia
- Access: Commons, Fair Use, Orphan Works, Public Domain
- Accounting
- Analog Holes
- Antitrust
- Art
- Aspen
- Big Tent
- Biotech
- Books
- Comments from Readers
- Counterfeit
- Digital Americas
- Digital Europe
- Digital Europe 2006
- DMCA
- DRM & Watermarks, etc.
- Economics, Game Theory & Public Choice
- Enforcement & Remedies
- Free Culture Movement
- Games
- General
- Infrastructure
- International
- Internet: P2P, Search Engines...
- Legislation and Legislators
- Liberty and IP
- Markets: Business, Investment & Innovation
- Media: Video, Music...
- Patents
- Pharma
- Physical Property
- Prices, Terms, and Licensing
- Privacy and Security
- Radio
- Software
- Spectrum & Wireless
- Standards
- Supreme Court
- Tax-Funded IP
- Telecom
- Theft of Service
- Universities
Links
 

Site Feed

  - Atom
- RSS 1.0
- RSS 2.0
We welcome comments by email - look for a link to the author's email address in the byline of each post. Please let us know if we may publish your remarks.


 
Home Page