Home Page
11. 6.2006 (previous | next)
Peculiar Gyrations

On Creative Commons Hack for Charity.

I have nothing against the Creative Commons license (or any other license for that matter), but I am beginning to find the economic gyrations that various organizations/entities go through in an attempt to support themselves without (gasps of horror) actually selling a product to a consumer rather ... surreal. Somebody must be spending a great deal of time constructing mental maps... it's okay to fund the provision of X to A by restricting the availability, not of X, but of Y, and by selling Y to C but not (god forbid) to A... One may accept money raised by the transfer of X service related to product to Y, but not from the transfer of product to Y. Oh dear. Is the resemblance to religion stronger than mere analogy?

posted by Solveig Singleton @ 8:43 AM | Access: Commons, Fair Use, Orphan Works, Public Domain, Free Culture Movement

Link to this Entry | Printer-Friendly | Email a Comment | Post a Comment(2)


Comments

Don't all charities and non-profits do this? I mean, Cato accepts donations from private individuals and they sell copies of their publications, but they don't do contract work or accept government money. The Catholic church accepts donations and allows you to sponsor various things (such as buying a brick for a new church) but they no longer sell indulgences. Firefox gives its browser away but accepts money from Google for prominent placement in their toolbar.

Non-profits seek funding mechanisms that don't compromise their mission. In CC's case, their mission is to increase the number of creative works that are freely available for re-mixing. Obviously, charging for creative works would not be the best way of promoting that mission. So in true entrepreneurial fashion, they're finding other ways of raising funds. I don't understand why you find this puzzling.

Posted by: Tim Lee at November 6, 2006 4:08 PM

How is charging for works "obviously" not the best way of promoting creative production.

I believe Solveig's point is that the "movement" aspect of CC often over complicates how creators can make money.

If they don't want to compromise their mission, then fine, they're like non-profits as you say. But CC is also involved in for-profit ventures, where making money is important.

I give the CC community credit for creativity though:):) An auction, who would have thought of that...

Posted by: Noel Le at November 6, 2006 6:03 PM








 
IPcentral WebLog

Blog Main

IPcentral Blogosphere Archives

Search the Blog

Recent Posts
  - IP and Marginal Cost
- Academics and Copyright
- More on Jammie Thomas from DOJ
- More Studies of Downloading
- Facebook, MySpace, and Network Externalities
- Copyright and the University: An Academic Symposium
- Tyler Cowan on Chinese Movie Piracy
- More WHO Antics--Roger Bate Reports
- Patents, Meds, and the Developing World: Clips & Links
- Jermaine Dupri's Gripe with iTunes
Archives by Month
  - December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
  - (see all)
Archives by Subject
  - Academia
- Access: Commons, Fair Use, Orphan Works, Public Domain
- Accounting
- Analog Holes
- Antitrust
- Art
- Aspen
- Big Tent
- Biotech
- Books
- Comments from Readers
- Counterfeit
- Digital Americas
- Digital Europe
- Digital Europe 2006
- DMCA
- DRM & Watermarks, etc.
- Economics, Game Theory & Public Choice
- Enforcement & Remedies
- Free Culture Movement
- Games
- General
- Infrastructure
- International
- Internet: P2P, Search Engines...
- Legislation and Legislators
- Liberty and IP
- Markets: Business, Investment & Innovation
- Media: Video, Music...
- Patents
- Pharma
- Physical Property
- Prices, Terms, and Licensing
- Privacy and Security
- Radio
- Software
- Spectrum & Wireless
- Standards
- Supreme Court
- Tax-Funded IP
- Telecom
- Theft of Service
- Universities
Links
 

Site Feed

  - Atom
- RSS 1.0
- RSS 2.0
We welcome comments by email - look for a link to the author's email address in the byline of each post. Please let us know if we may publish your remarks.


 
Home Page